In a galaxy far, far away, The Acolyte attempts to explore the shadowy secrets of the Sith and the dark side of the Force, setting the stage a century before the rise of the Empire. The series follows a former Padawan, played by Amandla Stenberg, who reunites with her Jedi Master, portrayed by Lee Jung-jae, to investigate a series of crimes. Their investigation leads them into the heart of a rising dark power, promising a fresh perspective that veers away from the well-trodden path of the Skywalker saga. However, the first two episodes reveal more about what the series fails to accomplish than what it hopes to achieve.
* * *
The Acolyte begins with the seductive allure of the Star Wars mythos, teasing the potential to explore the Sith’s rise. Yet, from the start, the series flounders in a sea of platitudes and uninspired storytelling, failing to capture the magic that once made this franchise a cultural phenomenon.
From the get-go, The Acolyte is burdened by its own self-importance. The dialogue is thick with pseudo-philosophical musings, but devoid of the wit and charm that made the original trilogy’s banter memorable. Characters speak in gravitas-laden tones, yet their words often feel hollow, lacking the spark of genuine emotion or insight. Amandla Stenberg’s character, a former Padawan with a chip on her shoulder, is a cardboard cutout of every disillusioned hero we’ve seen before. Her journey from reluctant investigator to reluctant hero is as predictable as it is uninspired.
One of the series’ biggest failures is its pacing. The first two episodes drag on with expository scenes that do little to advance the plot or develop the characters. Action sequences, when they finally arrive, are a flurry of CGI and shaky cam that fail to thrill or engage. There’s a distinct lack of tension, a crucial ingredient for any thriller, let alone one set in the high-stakes world of the Star Wars universe.
Visually, The Acolyte is a mixed bag. The production design and special effects are undeniably impressive, reflecting the vast resources at Disney’s disposal. The galaxy is rendered in sumptuous detail, from sprawling cityscapes to eerie, desolate planets. However, all this visual splendor cannot mask the hollowness at the series’ core. It’s like putting a fresh coat of paint on a decaying structure; the veneer may shine, but the rot beneath is unmistakable.
The cast, while competent, is given little to work with. Amandla Stenberg portrays the former Padawan with a monotonous intensity that quickly wears thin. Lee Jung-jae, known for his charismatic roles, seems adrift, unable to inject life into his stiff, underwritten character. Their dynamic, which should have been the emotional anchor of the series, lacks chemistry and depth. Supporting characters flit in and out of the narrative, often serving as mere plot devices rather than fully realized individuals.
The antagonists, supposedly the harbingers of the Sith’s resurgence, are a particular disappointment. They are shadowy figures with sinister plans, yet their motivations are nebulous and their menace underwhelming. The series attempts to build an aura of mystery around them, but this only highlights the lack of substantive threat they pose. In a universe where villains like Darth Vader and Emperor Palpatine have set the bar so high, these new baddies feel like pale imitations, lacking the gravitas and complexity that could have made them compelling.
Narratively, The Acolyte stumbles through a minefield of clichés and missed opportunities. The investigation that drives the plot is convoluted, mired in unnecessary subplots and red herrings that add confusion rather than intrigue. Moments that should have been revelations fall flat, and the series’ attempts at plot twists are telegraphed far in advance, robbing them of any impact. The world-building, a crucial aspect of any Star Wars story, feels half-hearted. Instead of expanding the mythology in meaningful ways, The Acolyte recycles old tropes and lore without adding anything new or exciting.
Perhaps the most egregious failure of The Acolyte is its inability to evoke the sense of wonder and adventure that defines the Star Wars franchise. There is no Han Solo swagger, no Princess Leia defiance, no Luke Skywalker heroism to rally behind. The series is bogged down by its own dark and brooding tone, mistaking somberness for depth. It lacks the lightness and joy that balanced the original trilogy’s darker moments, resulting in a viewing experience that is more slog than saga.
As the credits roll on the second episode, one is left with a sense of profound disappointment. The Acolyte could have been a bold new chapter in the Star Wars saga, an exploration of the dark side that revealed new truths about the Force and the galaxy far, far away. Instead, it is a cautionary tale of overreaching ambition and underwhelming execution. It tries to be many things—mystery, thriller, character study—but succeeds at none.
In these initial episodes, The Acolyte starkly reveals that even the most elaborate lore and lavish settings can’t salvage a story devoid of heart and originality. The Star Wars universe deserves far more than this tepid rehash of tired ideas, cloaked in shiny new robes but stripped of the vitality that once made it soar. It’s not merely a failure of storytelling but of imagination. One can only hope that future episodes learn from these missteps and somehow recapture the elusive magic of that galaxy far, far away.
Chris Montanelli
