Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery (2025)
Director: Rian Johnson
Writer: Rian Johnson
Stars: Daniel Craig (Benoit Blanc), Josh O’Connor (Rev. Jud Duplenticy), Glenn Close (Martha Delacroix), Josh Brolin (Msgr. Jefferson Wicks), Mila Kunis (Geraldine Scott), Jeremy Renner (Dr. Nat Sharp), Kerry Washington (Vera Draven), Andrew Scott (Lee Ross), Cailee Spaeny (Simone Vivane), Daryl McCormack (Cy Draven), Thomas Haden Church (Samson Holt), Jeffrey Wright (Langstrom), Annie Hamilton (Grace Wicks), James Faulkner (Reverend Prentice Wicks), Bridget Everett (Louise), Noah Segan (Nikolai), Joseph Gordon-Levitt (Baseball Announcer)
Release dates: September 6, 2025 (TIFF); November 26, 2025 (United States); December 12, 2025 (Netflix)
Plot: Father Jud Duplenticy, a former boxer turned Catholic priest in upstate New York, is reassigned after punching a rude deacon. He is made assistant pastor of Our Lady of Perpetual Fortitude, a rural parish led by Monsignor Jefferson Wicks. Wicks is the grandson of Reverend Prentice Wicks, who forced Jefferson’s mother, Grace, to remain at the church with the promise of receiving his inheritance, only for the fortune to disappear after his death; Grace ransacked the church and destroyed its crucifix, which the younger Wicks refuses to replace. Jud comes into conflict with Wicks over his incendiary preaching, which has driven away all but his most loyal parishioners. During a Good Friday service, Wicks dies suddenly in a storage closet near the pulpit, stabbed in the back with a knife fashioned from a devil’s head lamp adornment that Jud previously stole from a bar and threw through a church window. Though the evidence is inconclusive, suspicion falls on Jud.
Police chief Geraldine Scott summons private detective Benoit Blanc to investigate the death. He recruits Jud to assist him despite Scott’s objections, assured of his innocence. After Wicks’ burial in Prentice’s mausoleum, Jud and Blanc question the congregation, learning Wicks had abruptly disavowed his followers at a meeting just before his death. Failed politician Cy Draven reveals that Wicks allegedly found Prentice’s fortune and was planning to use it to pursue a career in politics with Cy, who he had learned was his illegitimate son. Jud drops out of the investigation, tired of Blanc’s singular focus on the murder and the mystery of the fortune, choosing instead to focus on his ministry.
While returning to his rectory at night, Jud appears to witness Wicks exit the mausoleum and embrace groundskeeper Samson. He is knocked out pursuing them and wakes up next to Samson’s corpse. Blanc stops Jud from turning himself in, having noticed a second adornment missing from the bar, stolen by town doctor and Wicks follower Nat Sharp. Blanc and Jud go to the doctor’s house and find his corpse dissolving in a tub of acid alongside Wicks’ body. The following morning, the police and the congregation convene in the church for Jud’s confession, only for Blanc to explain how Nat killed Wicks: he spiked Wicks’ private flask with tranquilizer and attached the second adornment to his vestment to fool Jud, covertly switching it out and stabbing Wicks whilst pretending to examine the body. Midway through his summation, however, Blanc has an epiphany and abruptly declares he cannot explain Wicks’ resurrection nor Samson’s murder, and the congregation leaves.
Before Scott can arrest Jud, Wicks’ former assistant, Martha, reenters, ready to confess: before his death, Prentice swallowed a valuable diamond, the key to Wicks’ fortune, which Grace sought in her desperation to escape the church. Jud’s earnestness persuaded Martha to confess this to Wicks, but she soon realized he was plotting to retrieve the diamond from Prentice’s corpse. To stop him from spreading his hate, she plotted his murder with Nat, persuaded Samson to be buried in Wicks’ place to retrieve the diamond, and had the two stage Wicks’ resurrection to restore faith in the church. When Nat killed Samson, framing Jud in the process, and tried to kill Martha to get the gem for himself, Martha tricked him into consuming a cup of coffee poisoned with pentobarbital meant for her. She collapses, having already taken the rest of the poison, which Blanc had realized during his denouement, hiding his final deduction to allow her to come forward on her own. With her last breaths, she prays for forgiveness from all victims including, at Jud’s urging, Grace. Jud performs absolution before she dies, and she drops the diamond.
One year later, Jud is about to reopen the church, now renamed Our Lady of Perpetual Grace. Most of the former parishioners have moved on with their lives, while a disgruntled Cy, the presumed heir to Prentice’s fortune, threatens to sue Jud, Blanc, and the church if the diamond is not returned, but they all proclaim ignorance. Blanc bids farewell as new parishioners enter for the first service of Jud, who hid the diamond inside the church’s new crucifix.
* * *
Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery (2025) | Transcript
[suspenseful string music plays]
[sighs]
[fire crackling]
[man] Hard to know where to start. I guess to tell the story of the Good Friday murder through my eyes, I got to start here. Nine months ago, when this asshole deacon said something way out of line, and I did this.
[imperceptible]
[grunts]
[thuds]
[priest gasps] Oh, shit.
So, you’re a fighter, then?
Uh, no, Father, absolutely not.
Well, we have a deacon who would say otherwise if his jaw wasn’t broken.
In my previous life, yes, I was a boxer, and I lived on the streets.
I did some other things.
We need fighters today, but to fight the world, not ourselves.
A priest is a shepherd.
The world is a wolf.
No.
[sighs softly] I… I don’t believe that, Father, respectfully.
[hesitates] You start fighting wolves, and before you know it, everyone you don’t understand is a wolf.
I still got that fighting instinct, and I gave into it today, but Christ came to heal the world, not fight it.
I believe that.
It’s this, not this, you know?
[inhales deeply]
I just want to be a good priest.
Show broken people like me the forgiveness and love of Christ.
The world needs that so bad.
You give me one more shot, and I promise I’ll do that.
[church bell tolling in distance]
[church bell continues tolling]
[vehicle horn honks]
[tolling stops]
Your Excellency, you stuck your neck out for me so many times.
I let you down, and whatever the…
All right.
Listen…
Deacon Clark is famously a dick.
Nobody’s actually that upset that you clocked him.
In fact, kind of the opposite.
But we do need to do something about it.
[exhales] We’re sending you to a small parish in Chimney Rock.
It’s just one priest there now.
[wind chime tinkling]
Assistant pastor?
Yeah, well, curb your enthusiasm.
What?
[sighs] You’re going to Our Lady of Perpetual Fortitude, led by Monsignor Jefferson Wicks.
Have you heard of Jefferson Wicks?
Okay, look, Wicks has his supporters here.
I’m not one of them.
Between you and me, I think he’s a few beads shy of a full rosary and a real son of a bitch.
[chuckles]
But what’s undeniable is that his flock is shrinking and even calcifying.
It could use some of what you said in there. You understand?
Not at all, but yes.
Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes.
Spirit’s got me. Let me at him.
Hey. Hey, hey.
This, not this, right? Mm?
Good luck, kid.
[intriguing music plays]
[Jud] So, that’s how I came to Chimney Rock. Daniel in the lion’s den. David facing off Goliath. Young, dumb, and full of Christ. Ready for anything.
[door creaks, closes]
[intriguing music continues]
[bag thuds]
[music fades]
[door creaking]
Father Jefferson?
Hello. Jud Duplenticy from Albany?
Lord be with you, Jud Duplenticy from Albany.
You here to take my church away from me?
[chuckling] Oh. No.
Good.
Okay, call me Monsignor Wicks.
I see you’ve met Martha.
Martha? No.
Monsignor Wicks.
Jesus!
I woke up early to polish the silver.
[sighs] It was a bit blotchy.
That’ll be fine, Martha.
Father… Jud.
You are welcome here.
Thank you, Martha.
Mm.
I was actually just saying to Father Wicks…
Monsignor Wicks.
Monsignor, right. Sorry. [chuckles] And sorry for saying “Jesus”.
Hoo. [chuckles] This is going great, I think.
Bishop Langstrom sent you, huh?
Mmhmm.
Langstrom.
I know him well.
[chuckles] He handpicked you, sent you here.
It says something to me.
Tells me a lot.
Well, I… I know you’re used to flying solo, but, um…
I’m… I’m here to serve.
Take my confession.
[Wicks groans] All right.
Mm.
[chuckles] Bless me, Father, for I have sinned.
It’s been, uh, six weeks since my last confession.
[inhales deeply, sighs]
I’ve envied the material wealth of others.
I saw this luxury car commercial.
Sam had it on his TV. Lexus.
And I thought, “Ah! That is a goodlooking car.”
[both chuckle] The coupe.
Uh… I’ve envied the power of great men.
Envied my grandfather’s power as a priest.
I wanted that.
Always did.
Uh…
I’ve masturbated, um, four times this week.
Four or five, generally, in…
What’d I say, six weeks?
Well, let’s say 30 times, masturbated.
Uh, this week, in my bed, in the morning once.
Once in the shower, standing up, which was convenient.
Just use a bath gel.
[inhales deeply]
Oh, once in the middle of the night, after a dream about…
That’s all right.
About one of those Japanese cat cafés.
Okay.
You know, I read this article, but the cats were girls, and, you know, so…
And I hadn’t prepared, so I had to finish into a copy of Catholic Chronicle magazine, just what was on the end table, which is probably its own kind of sin.
I don’t know, maybe not, but…
Not good. [chuckles] [Jud] At the time, I thought this was just weird.
[imperceptible]
But looking back now, I know. This was Wicks’ first punch. Five Hail Marys and one Glory Be.
Thank you, Father.
[Jud] It wouldn’t be his last. [Wicks] Oh, and welcome to my church.
[door opens, closes] [sighs] Over the next few weeks, I settled in at Our Lady of Perpetual Fortitude.
[intriguing music plays]
The only other fulltime employee was the groundskeeper, Samson. Sam. [Sam] It’s Monsignor Wicks who gives me the strength every day to not go back to the bottle.
He used to drink too.
[music fades]
But he said to me once, “If I can stave off that demon, you can.”
And every day, it is a struggle.
But I have.
I credit him and… my sweet Martha.
Your… your sweet Martha?
I’d do anything for her.
My angel on Earth.
[organ music playing] [Jud] As far as the church goes, Martha does it all. She keeps the books, manages donations, files everything. File that.
She launders the vestments, stocks the supplies, feeds Wicks, plays the organ. She knew where the bodies were buried. So this is the crypt?
[Sam] Yep.
It’s a damn shame.
Gotta put up a security camera.
[Jud] Is there an entrance?
There is.
This right here, it’s a Lazarus door.
Takes construction equipment to open from the outside.
But cantilevered as such that one push will send it tumbling to the ground from inside.
Who’s in there then?
Prentice.
[gasps] Wicks’ grandfather, the founder of this church.
Was like a father to me.
Makes me sick.
These kids painting rocket ships all over his sacred resting place.
[Wicks] What are you doing?
Oh, uh…
Well, I do a little woodworking, so thought I could borrow some of Sam’s tools, make a proper…
No, we leave that.
A reminder of the shameful sin of the harlot whore.
Take my confession.
[Martha] Yes, the harlot whore.
That was Wicks’ mother.
Okay, so what’s the deal with that?
She was a harlot and a whore.
Okay.
When Prentice entered the priesthood and founded this church, he was widowed with a daughter.
Grace was her name.
Always a bad seed.
She loved revealing clothes and her fancy brands.
Fancy brands… Oof.
Mm.
Yeah.
As a teenager, she slutted around bars, was soon pregnant by a drifter.
[imperceptible]
[Martha] Prentice had a vast family fortune in the bank.
[intriguing music plays]
To protect his grandson, Wicks, he promised that if Grace stayed under his roof, the fortune would be willed to her.
And so the whore waited for her father to die. Oh, it weighed on him heavily.
Martha, remember this.
Wealth and the power that comes with it, is Eve’s Apple.
Temptation that leads to the fall.
I must protect our loved ones from its corrupting influence, at all costs.
His day came at last. I was there.
I saw Prentice take his final communion and die on the holy altar. At peace.
The harlot whore went straight to Prentice’s attorney.
“Give me my money,” she said.
And do you know what he said?
“Yes, you are heir to every single penny Prentice had.”
And in his accounts, not one hot dime.
Mm, what did he do with the fortune?
Gave it to the poor, say some.
Threw it in the ocean, say others.
No one knows.
It was gone.
That holy man’s final act of grace was to keep the corrupting evil out of wicked hands.
All that he left her… was this.
“What is this?” she said.
But I knew.
Look not for Eve’s Apple.
Your inheritance is now Christ.
[ominous music swells]
[Martha] That night, she had her revenge. In a demonic rage, she defiled this holy place. [grunts]
[sinister music plays]
[grunting]
[screams]
[grunts, yells]
[grunts, yells]
[Martha] Blasphemy, desecration. Evil incarnate. [yells]
[music fades]
[Grace breathing heavily]
[squeals]
[grunts]
[breath trembling]
[low unsettling music plays]
[breathing heavily]
[sniffles]
[thunder rumbling]
[Martha] I said, “Sister Grace,” God, your Father, will forgive you in His love.”
[music fades]
[Martha screams] [yells] [grunting]
[yelping]
[menacing music plays]
[yelling]
[music stops] She died, throwing herself against Prentice’s tomb.
[screams]
[Martha] Brain aneurysm, they said.
Struck down, I say, by God in His mercy.
Holy shit.
Sorry, sorry.
[intriguing music plays]
[Jud] The darkness of that story was the bedrock of this place.
[Wicks speaks indistinctly]
[Jud] You could feel it.
And he asked, “Who told you…”
[Jud] So what would draw someone to make this their spiritual home? The core group of regulars all had their reasons. And these will be our suspects. So I should introduce them. Vera Draven, local attorney.
She was loyal and devoted.
[lock chirps]
[whistle blows]
[Vera] My dad was Wicks’ attorney and drinking buddy.
[chuckles] The boys.
And so you became a lawyer so you could take over his family practice?
I became a lawyer because I wanted to do great things in the world.
But this place is my dad’s legacy.
[spoon clatters] And he wanted me to…
Thank you.
…keep it going after he passed.
So here I am.
Yo, yo. Hey, Vera.
[door closes] Hi. Oh. Thank you.
Would you fill this up?
[Jud] Her adopted son, Cy, just moved back home after trying and failing to get a foothold in politics.
Hi.
Hey.
Okay.
It’s nice having him back?
[intriguing music plays]
[Jud] When Vera was young, just out of law school, her dad came home with ten-year-old Cy, out of the blue, and told Vera she was gonna raise him. No questions asked. The whole town knew he was obviously her illegitimate brother. But Vera accepted it. She did it.
I’ve given up a lot to… [inhales deeply] …be loyal to my dad and to Cy and to Wicks.
So I think that when my dad is looking down on me from heaven, I think he is very… [inhales deeply] …pleased with me.
So I guess that’s nice.
[Cy] I came this close. I was the GOP golden boy, the great hope.
I’ve got connections and ins and outs.
I was on the cusp, but I just couldn’t engage voters.
I didn’t… [inhales] have that cult of personality thing, I guess.
It’s hard connecting with people in a genuine way.
I know.
[Jud] Mmhmm.
I tried everything. Believe me, I hammered the race thing.
I hammered the gender thing, the trans thing, the border thing, the homeless thing, the war thing, the election thing, the abortion thing, the climate thing.
Thing about induction stoves, Israel, library books, vaccines, pronouns, AK47s, socialism, BLM, CRT, the CDC, DEI, 5G, everything.
All of it I did.
Nobody, just nothing. [sighs] People are just numb these days.
I don’t know why.
[hesitates] Maybe we need to get back to fundamentals, you know, basic building blocks on how to genuinely inspire people.
The basics, like, show them something they hate and then make them afraid it’s gonna take away something they love?
[soft intriguing music plays]
[hesitates] Well, no.
[indistinct chatter] Vera.
[Jud] Nat Sharp, the town’s local doctor.
[imperceptible]
His life revolved around his wife, Darla. She was his everything.
[music stops]
Darla left me last week.
[tuts] Oh, I’m sorry.
Took the kids, moved to Tucson with some guy that she met on a Phish message board.
[smacks lips]
Phish the band?
I had no idea.
[somber music plays]
[Jud] Dr. Nat was spinning out. He wasn’t successful enough, rich enough, good enough for her. He would do anything to get her back.
[intriguing music plays]
The closest thing we have to a local celebrity, the sci-fi writer Lee Ross. You probably know at least some of his books. The Crescent Limbo series, Ice Pick of Time, The Crystaline Juncture.
Ten years ago, Lee moved here from New York, connected with Wicks and the church, and as he puts it…
Unplugged my brain, you know, from the… [inhales] liberal hive mind and… [exhales] come here and…
[Jud] His book sales and popular standing have been in slow decline ever since. But he’d spent the last year writing a massive book about Wicks. His teachings, my reflections, essays and recollections of an acolyte at the feet of a prophet.
[Jud] The Holy Man and the Troubadour.
I found it a tough read, but he pinned all of his hopes on it.
This is my last chance ticket out of Substack hell.
I can’t take it anymore.
My readers these days…
I mean, they are survivalist freaks.
They all look like John Goodman in The Big Lebowski.
[chuckles]
[church bell tolling]
This little shitwick, Cy.
He’s got his little influencer fangs in the Monsignor lately.
We don’t like him. We’re all like, “Wicks. Be careful, you gotta shake him off.
He’s bad news. Opportunistic poetaster.”
We’re gonna have to protect Wicks from these leeching millennials.
[Jud] Simone was new to town, and new to the church. She’d been a world-class cellist.
[playing dramatic, somber tune]
Forced to retire five years ago for health reasons. Chronic pain. Some mysterious nerve thing that doctors cannot diagnose.
Sorry. [panting] I believed they could heal me.
[clicks tongue] Suckered.
Dipshit moi.
[breathes deeply]
I mean, to take someone’s faith and exploit it for money is the ultimate evil.
Don’t you think it is?
Yeah. Yeah, it’s bad.
But I understand wanting to believe.
This feels different, though.
[intriguing music plays]
Faith in God to heal me.
This is different.
I feel hopeful now.
Like a miracle could happen.
That’s how Monsignor Wicks makes me feel.
[intriguing music continues]
[wind gusting]
[indistinct chatter]
The Spirit really moved him today, huh?
[gasps] Monsignor!
Ah, my warrior.
[Jud] Wicks kept his core group tight. [laughs]
[Jud] And the seductive power of his charisma was undeniable. But his method… Every week, he would pick someone out, a newcomer usually, and he would attack.
The world wants us all to be okay.
Any of your choices.
Make your choices. They’re your choices.
Don’t feel bad.
Have that affair.
Tell that lie.
Have that child out of wedlock.
Satisfy your selfish heart.
Selfish.
Yes.
Depriving that child of a family.
Of a father.
An assault on our castle.
The institution of manhood.
My own mother made that selfish choice with me.
And I curse her selfish heart for it.
Every day of my life.
Putting her needs and wants before the family God intended.
I am enough!
Me!
[tense music plays] Selfish, harlot heart, you are not.
Might as well beat that child.
Yes, might as well starve that child.
Defy the family that the Lord intended.
And watch your child burn beneath that burden.
[music subsides]
[imperceptible]
[Jud] This is not the true church. You ask even the most hardcore of those in the pews, they’ll say, no, of course this is not what they believe. It’s Wicks being Wicks, pushing it too far. And what he’s pushing for every time is a walkout.
[intriguing music plays]
Why does he do this? Because when that person walks out, everyone watches. And even if in the light of day it’s indefensible, deep down in the dark, it scratches an itch.
[imperceptible]
[Jud] And by staying put in that pew, a side is taken. Wicks’ side. Testing tolerances, tapping deep poisoned wells, hardening, binding with complicity.
[man over radio] …for a tworun homer and that brings the Cubs… [grunts] Mm.
[Jud] So I try to offer a counterbalance.
[music fades]
Okay, welcome to our first Father Jud prayer group.
Um, thank you all for being here.
And this is all about breaking down walls between us and Christ, us and each other, us and the world.
When I was 17, I was a boxer and I… I… killed a man in the ring.
I built up so many walls of… of anger, addiction, violence.
It was only when I felt safe enough to… to put my dukes down, open my arms, um, confess my deepest sin.
That was the day that Christ saved my life.
It… He didn’t… He didn’t transform me.
He sustains me every day.
[clock ticking]
That’s daily bread, right?
I think that’s what the church should be.
That’s what I want this church to be, for me and for all of you.
[Vera chuckles softly] So…
Monsignor Wicks isn’t coming?
[hesitates] No, but…
No.
So, I thought we could just talk and start sharing and…
But he knows that we’re doing these?
Sure, of course. Of course, I’ll tell him.
I just… I wanted us to connect and, uh…
You’ll tell him?
You’ll… You’ll tell him?
Contraction of the simple future tense meaning you haven’t yet told him?
Why wouldn’t you tell him?
This feels kind of weird.
[Jud] Okay, guys.
[chuckles] This is a prayer meeting.
It’s… it’s not a secret or anything.
Well, it’s a secret prayer meeting.
No.
That’s literally what it is.
I just texted the Monsignor.
Great, so… [chuckles] it isn’t a secret anymore.
Now, if we could get back to breaking down those walls through Christ’s love…
[cell phone chimes]
He says, “What the holy heck?”
Oh.
Jeez.
[Vera] I’m… I’m sorry. Father, I came because I thought this was an official church function.
Only he didn’t use the word “heck”.
[laughs] Okay, thank you, Martha.
This is a church function, Vera.
It’s at a church.
It’s with me. It’s official.
Um…
Or “holy”.
Show… Can I see that?
I think I should go.
[Nat] Okay.
[Lee] Bye.
[Vera] Thank you. Uh, Cyrus?
Yeah.
[Nat] Oh, wow.
Yeah, sorry, Father.
I don’t want to piss him off.
Nice try, guy.
Thanks, Doc.
I’m probably gonna post this tomorrow.
Can I tag you?
I’d prefer you didn’t.
I probably will anyway.
I know.
[door opens]
[door closes]
I’m so sorry your little coup failed this afternoon, Father.
My coup? Martha, really?
If we want to pray or need to confess something, we can do it with Monsignor Wicks.
Can you? ‘Cause you all seem scared to death of the guy.
Could you walk into that church of your own free will and confess your deepest sin to Wicks, Martha, without fear?
‘Cause… ’cause if not, this whole place is a whitewashed tomb.
Yes, I could.
Well, good!
[church bell tolling]
[scoffs]
[groans]
[panting]
[exhales sharply]
[Jud] Holy Week, the week of special services leading up to Easter. It was on Palm Sunday that I finally broke.
[Wicks] And then, uh… twice in the shower this week doing that thing I told you about where I hold my hand upside down?
Five Our Fathers, five Hail Marys.
Well, we’re at nine months now, Jud.
How are you enjoying it here?
Are you breaking down some… walls?
Bless me, Father, for I have sinned.
It’s been a week since my last confession.
[inhales sharply]
I betrayed a fellow priest’s privacy.
I know that Martha keeps her medical bills filed in the office, so…
I went through them.
And I learned you had a radical prostatectomy five years ago, making you physically incapable of an erection.
I can handle whatever this is.
For the past nine months, I’ve seen the way you tend this flock, and I don’t like it.
You don’t like it?
No, Monsignor, I don’t.
Nat Sharp.
Man needs to forgive and start living his life.
And Christ’s love should be a launching pad for that, and instead, he’s just, every day, getting more and more angry and bitter against his ex-wife, against women.
[grunts] It’s bad. And Lee, he’s a storyteller.
And it’s like his superpower has been turned against him.
The only story he tells is, “The world is out to get me.”
He was brilliant funny, and smart and respected, and now he’s just spinning out and angry all the time, paranoid.
Did you know he literally built a moat around his house?
Really?
[Jud] I mean, it’s mostly symbolic, but yeah.
And Simone, I’m sorry, Monsignor, but I’m afraid you’ve taken advantage of her.
I’ve seen the donation numbers.
I know how much she’s giving, and the past few months, she’s basically supporting this place.
And yes, I believe in the possibility of miracles through Christ, but what you’re giving her is not that.
It’s transactional, through you, and God help you, it makes her feel betrayed again.
God help me. Anything else?
Yeah, why not? Cy Draven.
Doesn’t this new YouTube stuff he’s doing worry you? Every week now, he takes clips from what you say in Mass and plugs them into his political rants.
He’s coopting, and honestly, I think misrepresenting the church in a dangerous way.
[sighs]
When was the last time a new person lasted more than one Sunday?
Word’s gotten out.
Every week now, it’s just this… this hardened cyst of regulars, and it seems like you’re intentionally keeping them angry and afraid.
Is that how Christ led his flock?
Is that what we’re supposed to do?
[grunts] [groans]
[crows cawing, fluttering]
[coughing] Right now, you’re angry. You should be.
It’d be dangerous if you weren’t.
I’d see you’re helpless, and I’d do it again and again.
I’m the world. You’re the church.
Stay there. Stay there. Stay.
[groaning] Aha. Good. Right. Yes.
[pants, grunts] Anger. Anger lets us fight back, take back the ground we’ve lost.
And we’ve lost so much ground.
And now you’re afraid.
Look at those bareknuckle instincts coming back. Good!
You’re afraid I’m gonna come at you again.
But you’re protecting yourself.
[pants, exhales] Because the world wants to destroy us.
Your version of love and forgiveness is a sop.
It’s going along to get along with modernity, not wanting to offend this garbage world.
Meanwhile, they destroy us.
Feminist Marxist whores.
Bit by bit, they do.
But I carry my burden. I hold the line.
And you?
You simpering child from Albany?
Are you gonna get angry and fight?
You’re poisoning this church.
And I’ll do whatever it takes to save it.
To cut you out like a cancer.
Five Our Fathers, five Hail Marys.
[door opens]
[Jud] Christ, you didn’t give up on me. I’m not giving up on this church.
[thunder rumbling]
But he was one step ahead of me.
[Wicks] Father Jud’s prayer meeting?
I have kept this church.
I have fortified it with the truth of God.
And now the betrayal to find my authority and faith and life itself challenged, and from inside my own sanctuary.
Get out!
[door slams]
[breathing heavily]
[Jud] Wicks’ final move. Open war against me.
[rock music plays over speakers]
[lively chatter]
[Jud] I got pretty toasty.
The world’s a wolf. You devil.
You devil wolf.
You’re a devil wolf.
Shit.
Oh! Nikolai, I’m sorry. I broke that…
No, no, no. Don’t worry about it.
…with my hand.
They’re junk lamps. They’re junk lamps.
Come on. Hey, are you good to drive?
Yeah.
Are you sure?
[suspenseful music plays]
[grunts]
[glass shatters]
[Sam] Hey!
[gasps] Who’s there?
Oh, shit.
[Jud] And that brings us to Good Friday. Here we go. It was a 3:00 p.m. service. Just the regulars. There was a strange tension in the air. I can’t recall the homily, but it felt different. The anger felt less calculated. More unhinged. [imperceptible]
[suspenseful music continues]
[Jud] As always, after the homily, Wicks was spent, emotionally and physically, and needed some time to recover. He would duck into the small storage closet just to the side of the sanctuary so he’d be out of sight. He’d fortify himself, and I would continue the service until he felt strong enough to rejoin and take over.
♪ Behold the wood of the cross ♪
♪ On which hung
The salvation of the world ♪
[thudding]
[object clangs]
[Jud] Monsignor?
[low suspenseful music plays]
What’s wrong?
Jefferson?
[suspenseful music rises]
Jud.
There’s something in his back.
[Nat] Wait. Don’t touch it.
Don’t… don’t touch anything.
[music intensifies]
[screaming]
Satan! Satan struck him down!
The devil… Satan…
[Vera] Martha.
…struck him down!
Oh, no.
[Martha screaming] [Vera] Martha! Please.
[sinister dramatic music plays]
[music stops]
[fire crackling]
[thunder rumbles in distance]
[Jud] The ambulance took just five minutes to arrive.
[sirens chirp]
[sirens wailing] [Jud] Wicks was pronounced dead on the scene. When I joined the others outside, the police were just arriving.
[Martha] The devil will not take that man. [sniffles] He will rise again in the glory of the Lord.
[Jud] This was an insane event for a tiny town, and poor Geraldine, the local chief, was thrown in headlong.
Christ.
Hours of questioning all through the day Saturday until finally…
[Geraldine] You’re the only one on stage with the Monsignor at the time of his killing.
And you had prior possession of the wolfhead figurine attached to the murder weapon.
And you’re the only one at that church who hated his guts.
I… I don’t hate any guts.
But it’s literally impossible for anyone to have done this, so I don’t…
[sighing] Oh, I don’t know what this is.
All right. Father, why don’t you go get some rest?
But I should warn you before you walk out of here, the town is talking.
Cy Draven put this up on his YouTube this morning.
[Jud on recording]
…poisoning this church. And I’ll do whatever it takes to save it. To cut you out like a cancer. [exhales]
[Geraldine] It’s been reposted.
Quite a bit.
[intriguing music plays]
[indistinct police radio chatter]
[object crunches]
[music turns suspenseful]
[Jud] I turned on my phone for two minutes, and that was a mistake. A flood of messages to the killer priest. But I wasn’t thinking about getting arrested or defrocked. I was thinking Wicks had won. Because in the part of my soul that cannot lie to Christ, or myself, or you…
[door creaking]
[door thuds]
…I was happy the old man was dead.
[solemn music plays]
[exhales]
Jesus.
Help me. [sniffles] Show me the way through this, please.
[music fades]
[man] Hello?
Oh, I’m sorry. Um…
Are you open?
Always.
You all right?
Yeah. Uhhuh. Sorry. [sniffles] Uh, there’s no Easter Mass. I’m sorry.
Oh, I’m…
You’re welcome. Come in. Come in.
Thank you. Thank you.
I don’t want to take you away from your priestly duties now, do I?
[Benoit clicks tongue]
Well… [chuckles] Isn’t this something?
[Jud] Right?
It’s… hard to be in here and not feel His presence.
Whose?
Oh. God… Oh. Yeah. [laughs] Yeah.
You’re not a Catholic.
No, very much not, no. [chuckles] Proud heretic.
I kneel at the altar of the rational.
Uhhuh. You weren’t raised in the faith?
My mother is… was, uh, very, very religious, you know.
Were you close with her?
No.
When I was a boy, we, um… But it’s…
Complicated. Family.
[chuckles] It’s complicated.
Yeah. That’s right.
How does all this make you feel?
How does it make me feel?
Truthfully?
Sure.
Well, the architecture, that interests me.
I feel the grandeur, the… the mystery, the intended emotional effect.
It’s… [exhales] And it’s like someone has shone a story at me that I do not believe.
It’s built upon the empty promise of a child’s fairy tale filled with malevolence and misogyny and homophobia and its justified untold acts of violence and cruelty while all the while, and still, hiding its own shameful acts.
So like an ornery mule kicking back, I want to pick it apart and pop its perfidious bubble of belief and get to a truth I can swallow without choking.
[spluttering] The rafter details are very fine, though. It’s…
Listen… you want to kick me out, you go right ahead.
No, no.
You’re being honest, it’s good.
Telling the truth can be a belly rub.
[chuckles softly] Now, I suspect you can’t always be honest with your parishioners.
You can always be honest by not saying the unhonest part.
Yeah. [laughs] You’re right. It’s storytelling.
And this church, it’s… it’s not medieval. We’re in New York.
It’s neoGothic 19th century.
It has more in common with Disneyland than NotreDame…
[chuckles] …and the rites and rituals and costumes, all of it.
It’s storytelling.
You’re right.
I guess the question is do these stories convince us of a lie?
Or do they resonate with something deep inside us that’s profoundly true?
[clicks tongue] That we can’t express any other way… except storytelling.
Touché. Padre.
[laughs, sobs]
Son.
I’m sorry.
I just…
I just felt like a priest again, and now I’m gonna lose that and… and lose my purpose and I’m frightened, I…
I don’t know how I’ll live.
[door opens] [Geraldine] Blanc!
Hey! You found him! Is he…
[indistinct police radio chatter]
[door closes]
[chuckles] Who are you?
I probably should have led with this.
My name is Benoit Blanc. I’m a detective.
I’ve taken an interest in the murder of Jefferson Wicks.
You’re a detective, so you’re with the police?
No, no. I work in a private capacity.
Everyone thinks I did it. I didn’t do it.
But in my heart maybe I did, and the way it happened was some kind of miracle.
And…
I don’t know. I’m lost. I don’t know.
Would you allow me to help you?
What?
Your lips are cracked with dehydration.
You haven’t slept all night.
You spent it out of doors, by the state of your pant legs, on your knees in prayer.
What I see is not a guilty man in torment, but an innocent man tormented by guilt.
Let me help you.
How?
This was dressed as a miracle.
It’s just a murder and I solve murders.
[inhales]
Wait… [hesitates] Were you the Kentucky Derby thing with the murder and the guy that they caught with the photofinish camera?
Yeah.
So you’re…
You were on The View. Yeah.
What are you doing here?
I need to come up to speed rapidly on the events of that Good Friday service and the goingson here at Our Lady of Perpetual Fortitude.
Geraldine has graciously allowed me access.
If you can spare the day and accompany me on my investigation, view the body, trace the murder weapon, inspect the crime scene, you are in a unique position to assist me.
The body?
[unsettling string music plays]
[music fades]
Yeah, I’ve changed my mind.
I don’t think I should be here.
Blanc, I’m trusting your process, but I agree with him.
No, no, no. I want you to get a clear clinical picture of what happened here.
To see Wicks as he is, a corpse.
Just an empty vessel.
Not the mythologized monster in your mind, but merely flesh and blood.
Dead from a knife wound we can analyze.
Just… flesh and blood.
Flesh and blood, yeah.
Yes, that’s our wiggly wiggly. [chuckles] Yeah. Look at that.
Please stop doing that.
Tammy. Would you mind flipping the meat?
[Tammy] Mm.
Pancake him. Yeah.
[Benoit] Mmhmm.
[Geraldine clears throat]
[Tammy, muffled] One, two, three.
[body thuds]
[panting]
Hey! Hey.
No, no, no. I don’t belong here.
I can’t be in here, I don’t know why you brought me.
I can’t…
Hey!
If you want absolution, you want ever to be a priest again, then you need to go through this with me.
The real killer is out there.
We’ve got to find him, nail him, I…
I’m sorry.
I mean, catch him and get your life back.
[door opens, closes] Father.
I need to know you understand the situation.
We are not all buddies running around trying to solve a case.
You are still a suspect.
The point is, you do not need to be here without a lawyer, do you understand that?
[intriguing music plays]
[breathing heavily] I didn’t do this.
If I can help find out who did, then I’m in, yeah, let’s do it, yeah.
Okay.
The body.
Next the murder weapon.
Then the crime scene.
Stick with me.
[intriguing string music plays]
[music stops]
I’ll tell you something, I don’t even like the devil.
You know, Il Diavolo, it sounds classy, Italian, that’s fine, you know, then my wife, she buys a devil sign, then she buys the devil lamps and then people start, “Oh, hey, get him a devil thing for the bar, he loves it.”
And then, you know, uh, devil, devil, devil, bang, I don’t know.
[Benoit] But that… But that’s it, right?
[Nikolai] Yeah.
[Benoit] Oh, yeah.
[rock music plays faintly over speakers] [Nikolai] But, uh…
But you know, it wasn’t red though, it’s red now, it’s paint.
Yes, yes, freshly painted.
I hope. Hmm.
They filled it with some kind of plaster and stuck the blade in that way.
[Jud on recording] I’ll do whatever it takes to save it. To cut you out like a cancer.
[Nikolai] Hey, hey, hey. Come on, ixnay.
That’s not cool. Come on.
The red devil head thing, that ended up where?
In the church, I threw it at the church and it broke a window, I don’t know why.
[church bell tolling]
[gasps] [Jud] And then after the Chrism Mass on Monday, Martha said she found a small broken window. Kids.
But nothing else.
[over speakers] ♪ I know what’s wrong
I don’t confuse it ♪
♪ All I’m really trying to say is ♪
♪ Why should the devil have
All the good music? ♪
♪ I feel good every day ♪
♪ Because Jesus is the rock
And he rolled my blues away ♪
[Benoit] Do you see that?
♪ They say to cut my hair
They’re driving me insane… ♪
[Benoit] Hmm.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Oh. That is, uh…
Dr. Nat.
Oh, f…
[clears throat] Hey.
Just having some lunch.
[clears throat]
Nat, I… I can come over later if… if you want to talk.
I don’t think… Yeah, I… Yeah.
I don’t think I’d prefer that.
I’d prefer not that.
Ah, there it is.
Here’s what you did it with. Huh?
Come on, Nat.
“Cut him out like a cancer.”
You son of a bitch.
[man] You tell him, Nat.
Yeah.
Son of a bitch! Killer priest!
[door slams]
[intriguing suspenseful music plays]
[thudding] [TV plays indistinctly] First off, I owe Detective Elliott a fruit basket for giving me your number.
I’m just glad to be of service.
Geraldine, you had the foresight to see that this goes way beyond normal police work, this is something even I have not experienced.
A textbook example of a perfectly impossible crime.
The stuff of detective fiction.
This should not exist in our real world.
And yet here it is.
The holy grail.
[Geraldine] I love the passion.
I just need to feel confident you know this case is solvable.
[Benoit] I’m incapable of not solving a crime.
That moment of checkmate when I take the stage and unravel my opponent’s web…
Oh, you’ll see. It’s fun!
Great, how do we get there?
[Benoit] The source, John Dickson Carr’s The Hollow Man. A Golden Age detective novel and a veritable primer on the lockeddoor mystery, the impossible crime.
Hold up.
[intriguing music plays]
Father Jud, once again, earning your keep. [chuckles] Whose Body?
The Murders in the Rue Morgue. Roger Ackroyd.
The Murder at the Vicarage. My God, this is practically a syllabus for how to commit this crime.
And the whole flock is in this group?
Who chose these books?
Oprah.
Oprah.
Martha pulls a theme list from Oprah’s site.
Well, this confirms my theory.
The killer certainly imitated the traditional methods of a lockeddoor mystery story.
Which makes things simple.
Book club time.
Come on, kids.
[music fades]
In The Hollow Man, the detective Gideon Fell gives a rundown of all possible methods of a lockeddoor killing. [chuckles smugly] So let’s line them up and knock them down.
Possibility number one, Wicks was stabbed with the knife before entering the closet.
Father Jud, would you take your place right where you were?
Wicks completes his sermon.
Any device behind him capable of propelling a heavy unbalanced dagger into his back… would have been hidden from the camera and the witnesses in the nave, but certainly would have been witnessed by Father Jud.
No, I didn’t see a knifeshooting robot behind him.
[Benoit] No. Possibility one, nixed.
Possibility two…
He was killed while inside the closet by someone or something that was outside the closet.
Like, something shot the knife into the closet from out here?
No, that’s nuts.
Nuts and impossible on several fronts.
Possibility two, nixed. Progress!
[sighs] How many more possibilities are there?
Not many. Three…
He was killed while inside the closet by a device that was also inside the closet.
So something was placed beforehand and, what, triggered with a remote?
Well, these walls are thick, but a very strong RF signal could blast through ’em.
So where would one hide…
[lightbulb clinks] …a fully functional remotecontrolled knifepropelling device in an empty box, mm?
Wicks fell on his stomach.
[intriguing music plays] I remember that clangy thud.
[thudding] [object clangs]
[Jud] And his face was towards the door, so he was standing at the back facing out, so the knife must have somehow come through the back wall.
Clangy thud. Very good.
However, Rock of Gibraltar.
What about…
What about a false wall that was removed later?
Go to town, Father Brown.
[Geraldine] What? No, no.
My boys would have noticed a fake wall.
[switch clicking]
Yeah. And removing it later would have been no small task.
Nothing else was found on the floor of this space, yes?
Nope. No, just the red thread.
Wait, what? The…
The red thread?
[music rises, fades]
Two strings of thick red thread about three inches long, found there over by the body next to the hip.
So, what’s possibility four?
[Martha sobbing]
Martha?
[Martha] Throw them out.
[Jud] Martha?
[Martha] Throw them out!
[sobbing] To walk this holy place like some crime scene. Like some tawdry police show talking of robots!
It’s not right, Father, it isn’t, it’s not right!
[door opens]
[door closes]
Martha, you should go home, get some rest.
Can I do anything for you?
Leave.
No one wants you here anymore.
You’ve always hated the Monsignor and you have nothing but contempt for us.
That’s not true.
Murder in your heart…
No.
…blood on your hands just like the harlot whore.
Your original sin has stained this place.
False priest!
Sorry.
[gasps softly] But, yeah, if finding the facts with that detective puts me against you and this flock then so be it.
Sorry.
[music turns melancholic]
[grunting]
[music fades]
Can I use your bag? [grunting] Sure. Go ahead.
[continues grunting]
[TV plays indistinctly]
Are you okay?
[Jud] A fog was clearing.
This was a puzzle that was solvable. The body, the weapon, the crime scene, robot-knife guns, and angles of view and stone walls and remote controls. [panting]
[organ music plays on TV] And remote controls.
[commentary on TV] But it’s a new day…
The Cubs… who would have been the hero in that game… But we saw how that went…
You didn’t listen to the game during Friday’s service.
On your radio.
I would not. Martha doesn’t approve.
[commentary continues] So you taped it.
Yep.
Okay. I’ve overlaid a time stamp taking into account the broadcast delay.
Dr. Sharp’s call to the hospital happened at 3:47 p.m.
and 90 seconds before that…
[keyboard clacking]
So, several things could have caused that glitch, but to answer your question, yes, it is consistent with a strong burst of RF interference that you might get from a soupedup remote control.
[chuckles in relief] Damn.
This is it, right?
This triggered the knife robot.
[sucks teeth] This has got to be it.
You can… You can solve it now, right?
Did you, um…
Did you sync this up with Cy’s footage?
I did, yeah. The iPhone video has a time stamp. It’s very precise.
Okay. Can you show us please?
Yeah.
Show us what?
[Jud] ♪ On which hung
The salvation of the world ♪
[thudding]
[object clangs]
[Jud] Monsignor?
[keyboard clacks] Oh.
[Benoit groans] So when the RF burst happened, he was already on the ground with a knife in his back and Father Jud was staring right at him.
How does that work?
Well, for the knife robot, it doesn’t.
So… this was nothing?
[Benoit] No, no.
This was very much something.
[inhales deeply]
We have all the pieces laid out before us now.
We do?
Yeah.
Consider the origin of the devil’s head, the red thread, the clangy clunk, the timing of the RF remote.
It all lines up.
[chuckles uncertainly]
So give us the answer.
I can’t.
You said if you had all the pieces, you would have an answer.
[Benoit] I know. And yet, with all the pieces on the table, this crime still truly appears impossible.
You told me you could solve this.
[solemn music plays]
That’s what you do.
[sighs] I put my faith in you.
Oh, God. Oh, God. [sighs]
[Benoit] You haven’t slept in 36 hours.
I think it’s bedtime. [clears throat] Yeah.
It’s been a hell of a day.
Good night, Father Jud.
Come on. I’ll drive you back.
[intriguing music plays]
[music fades] You know, you’re right.
This can’t be impossible.
There must be a piece missing.
And I think I know where to find it.
See, I think there’s something in there, in your head, that I need to solve this case.
And if I can’t shake it loose, I’m sorry, but I’m gonna have to go in there and get it.
Okay, you’re freaking me out now.
I don’t… I don’t understand.
[door closes] I don’t get how this will help.
You want me to write the story?
Yes, the story.
The story of the Reverend Wicks’ murder.
Monsignor Wicks.
Monsignor Jalapeño. I don’t care.
I need to see his murder and the events leading up to it through your eyes.
Starting where?
Oh, wherever you like.
Just keep it interesting, keep it moving and spare no detail.
Blanc, I’m not a writer.
Take your time. Oh.
[chuckles] I’ll be quite comfortable.
[cork squeaks]
[glass clinks]
[liquid pours]
[Benoit humming]
[intriguing suspenseful music plays]
[Jud] So I’ve spent the past hour doing exactly that and now I’ll put down this pen and hand it to you and I guess, wait while you read my story of the murder of Monsignor Jefferson Wicks.
[intriguing suspenseful music continues]
[sighs softly]
[sighs]
[music fades]
Why’d you do it?
Better question is, why’d I think I could lie to you and get away with it?
Oh, no, you didn’t lie.
I knew you wouldn’t.
You just didn’t say the dishonest part out loud.
[suspenseful music plays]
“When I joined the others outside, the police were just arriving.”
[distant sirens wailing]
[suspenseful music continues]
“Joined the others outside.” So you stayed inside. So you were the only person with unobserved access to the utility closet after the murder, but before the police searched it.
Why? I mean… [scoffs] Why protect him?
I didn’t do it to protect Wicks.
I did it to save the people who believe in him just a little disillusionment.
Well, surely everyone knew.
I mean, it would have been on his breath after every Mass. “Fortified himself.”
Oh, clever wording there. But everyone must have known. The spirit really moved him today, huh?
No, not everyone.
Sam.
The one good person in this whole place.
Getting sober saved his life.
I knew the press and police were there.
Why let that be part of the story?
[clangs]
[Jud] Wicks had been stabbed. I don’t know how or by who, but I… but I knew he’d been stabbed. So this had nothing to do with it. It was an impulse.
A little storytelling to protect my flock.
Oh, bullshit!
And in protecting their bubble of belief, you have shielded a killer!
Where is that flask?
[objects clattering]
[Jud] Shit!
Shit. It’s not here. [panting]
[music fades]
Blanc.
I’m sorry.
He was stabbed, so I didn’t think…
No. You did not think.
But we’re into the woods now, so you better start.
[panting]
Someone broke into my room.
It’s just hitting me.
This is devious, it’s calculated against me.
And now you see the enemy we’re up against.
You have listened to this flock’s stories with empathy and grace, but we’re done with that now.
We’ve wasted enough time.
Tomorrow we use the gathering at the burial to question them all together.
We must discover what happened that night.
And what this flock of wicked wolves is hiding.
[snoring]
[Benoit] Mm.
[sighs]
Betrayed.
Beaten.
Mocked.
Pierced.
[tense music plays]
Murdered.
[thudding]
[machine whirs]
And left in a hole to rot. To be forgotten. As with our Savior, so with the church. Our church is assailed by wicked modernity, by the enemies of God. The harlot whores, the vermin who would oppress and silence and bar us from our rightful place as the rulers of a Christian nation of faith.
And even as I stand before you as a warrior of Christ, in the armor of God ready to fight the world to my last breath, you shall not pass!
As our Lord was, I am betrayed by Judas. Gentlemen, may I have a moment?
[Wicks] Judas in many forms.
[melancholic music plays]
Always the true threat comes from within. Remember my words. On this Good Friday, remember what’s to come. Remember, all of you.
[Martha crying]
You will rise again.
It will be okay.
You will rise again.
You will rise.
[Wicks] The hour approaches.
The hour I have warned you about.
Remember what I have promised you all, come Easter Sunday.
For I will make good on that promise, yes, I will.
[dramatic music plays]
[Wicks] For behold, though He is struck down, the righteous Son of God will rise again. Eve’s Apple restored to the tree and the wealth of His kingdom and His rising reign. And as you gnash your teeth in the darkness, you unfaithful devils, as you lie cold and forgotten and alone, He will rise again to reclaim what is His.
And strike down the wicked and raise His true Son to the throne of this nation!
Yes, He will rise! Yes, He will rise!
Yes, tremble in fear, for He will rise again in glory and vengeance and power!
[music fades]
[machine whirs, hisses]
[forklift beeping]
Sorry about your loss, Father.
Here, sign on the bottom. [clears throat] Listen, between you and me, I don’t care what the Internet says.
I think there’s a chance you didn’t do it.
[pats back]
All right, everyone. Listen up.
Oh, would you look who it is.
It’s Judas Jud.
[scoffs] Father, you are not welcome here.
All right, stop!
Here’s what’s gonna happen.
Benoit fricken’ Blanc and I are gonna ask you all some questions, you’ll answer them and we’ll get to the bottom of who killed Monsignor Wicks and why and then…
That’s it!
Okay? Okay, so…
Thank you, Father Jud, that was very good. Um, and we’re gonna start… [sighs] …with what happened that night right here in this very room.
You mean the time Jud admitted to all of us that he killed a man.
Okay, no, that was…
That was the boxing thing, I was…
And now he’s covering his ass by attacking us. He’s a PINO.
A… a PINO?
Priest in name only.
Helping Benoit Blanc crack the mystery of the evil, evil church and then some libtard will make a podcast about all of this and before you know it, the idiot versions of all of us will end up on Netflix.
Oh, the idiot versions. God forbid.
[screams]
[shrieks]
[Nat] Jesus!
It’s a miracle!
I can walk, Martha. It just hurts.
[exhaling] Oh.
[sighs] Oh.
And I say, good.
Expose it all.
Wicks was a con man.
Miracles and supernatural power of God bullshit.
[scoffs] I really believed.
I still wanna believe.
[scoffs] How sick is that?
Well, actually, I was inquiring not about Jud’s prayer group, but about the shadowy meeting with Wicks that took place in this room on Palm Sunday.
[imperceptible]
[suspenseful sting plays]
[Benoit] What was that meeting actually about?
Who wants to go first?
I’ll tell you.
[Nat] Cy. Hey. Wait, hold on, buddy. Hey!
[Lee] No, no, no.
You shut your mouth, you little shit weasel.
It isn’t your decision!
Tell him nothing!
Hey, look… Whoa. Easy, Father Jud.
I promise you that what we talked about that night has nothing to do with Wicks’ killing, okay?
But it does have to do with things that, if made public, could ruin people in this room.
I recorded the whole thing. Just hit play.
[Martha] No! This is not…
[Lee] You scoundrel!
Open this door, you bastard!
You are defiling my files!
Play it.
[Lee] Open it…
[clock ticking]
[footsteps approaching]
[Wicks] All right. Very dramatic, Vera.
You’ve got your audience.
What’s this about?
I’ve been thinking about your mom.
I never knew her, but growing up in this church, I knew the story of the harlot whore and I’ve been thinking about what her life must have been like to be trapped in a house, with her father and her son.
Closing rank, shaming her and teaching us all to shame her.
That poor girl.
[clicks tongue, inhales]
Yesterday, I got a call from a family law colleague in Brooklyn.
[smacks lips] He wanted to doublecheck contact details for Monsignor Jefferson Wicks, my client, because my client had filed an AOP with him.
In Brooklyn.
So I would not know.
What’s an AOP?
“Acknowledgement of parentage”?
“Affirmation that I, Jefferson Wicks, am the biological father of Cyrus Draven.”
[Vera] No shame for you.
Right? [scoffs] Who was the mother?
Does it even matter?
No. No! [scoffs] No, she came back and dropped this poor kid in your lap.
And then she went and had a life.
And my faithful father came to the rescue.
Once again, the boys club closed ranks and there I was, the loyal little idiot.
Trapped.
And I obeyed and I honored and raised your son while you sat on your pulpit, shameless.
You… hypocritical son of a bitch!
[breathing heavily]
[Wicks exhales softly]
[Nat] Cy?
Did you know?
Not until Vera told me this morning.
[Wicks] Yes.
Cy is my son.
From a loose woman of no importance who I knew for one night and haven’t seen in 30 years.
Vera’s father and I kept this secret.
But no longer.
He is my heir.
My son.
Now the world is going to know it.
So, rats, flee the sinking ship.
[Nat clears throat]
Oh, cut the shit.
You’re all standing by your man.
[scoffs] I just wanted to see it.
I wanted to see for myself.
You eat his shit with a spoon and come back for seconds.
[Lee] That’s kind of condescending, Vera.
You don’t know what we’re feeling.
[scoffs] Oh.
I think we’re all, as Christians, very shaken up by what you just said.
But we’re fighting an existential war here where the end justifies the means.
The church doesn’t need some pussy who’s gonna lie down and take it, we need a warrior.
We need a warrior and I believe that God chose Monsignor Wicks to be His warrior.
So, you and your son have my sword.
And… we don’t know this woman.
We do not know her.
We do not know, right, how she…
What is truth? Right?
With various sources.
We don’t know that… We don’t…
[hesitates] What exists?
Does any of this exist?
So…
Well said, Doc.
Thank you.
[Simone] You promised if I stuck with you, you could heal me.
If that’s true, I don’t need you to be a saint.
[Lee] We’re with you, Monsignor Wicks.
And literally nothing that you say or do is gonna change that.
[inhales deeply]
I will give my final service a week from today on Easter Sunday.
And then I will close the doors of this sad little church for good.
[Wicks breathes deeply]
But not before I have destroyed each and every one of you.
[tense music plays]
Sorry. Wait, what?
Your drinking, Nat?
Yeah. What?
Oh, you’re a dangerous man.
Going to work drunk.
Treating patients, children, while drunk.
This community should know.
The medical board should know.
No one must ever trust or hire you again.
And, Lee.
This, uh, Troubadour book you’ve been writing.
Its boot licking idiocy is an affront to my ministry.
It… It’s my duty to warn not only the public but… [inhales] …my friends in the publishing world.
It must be buried. You must be buried.
Exposed as the irrelevant clown that you are.
What the hell?
What is even happening right now?
[Wicks] And, Vera.
You are your father’s nightmare.
He would be so ashamed.
Simone. I cannot heal a faithless woman.
I cannot help you.
You said you could cast it out of me.
Mm, I promised you nothing.
I’ve given you all of my savings.
You cannot buy God’s healing.
You will never be healed.
You will die in pain in the prison of that chair.
Why are you doing this?
I don’t understand.
[Lee] This is a joke. Right? A joke.
[Nat] I am so confused.
Is this payback for the Father Jud prayer meeting because he ambushed us.
Father Jud’s prayer meeting?
I have kept this church.
I have fortified it with the truth of God.
And now the betrayal to find my authority and faith and life itself challenged…
[door opens] …and from inside my own sanctuary!
Get out!
[door slams] Weak.
All of you.
You can’t follow my path.
Yes, we are at war and I cast you out of my fortress.
You son of a bitch.
On Easter Sunday, when the pews fill with townspeople, I will lay bare the sins of this flock.
Cut you loose and shake the dust of this place off of my sandals.
And to hell with you all.
[sinister music rises]
[music stops]
[inhales sharply] Well, glory be.
That cleared the room. [scoffs] Cy.
Why’d he do that?
[sighs]
[Jud] Cy. Tell me. What was happening?
Why’d he torch them all?
Why would he do that?
Because I told him to.
When Vera told me the truth, I went and found him.
And he embraced me as a son for the first time in my life.
He unburdened himself.
[Wicks] I hate this place.
I hate this sad flock of losers.
I want to get out.
And now, finally…
I can.
He told me, his grandfather’s family fortune, lost all these years, he told me he found it. Just this week.
No. No, that money is gone.
Nobody knows where Prentice put it, but it’s gone without a trace.
He told me he found it.
[chuckles derisively]
[Cy] He was gonna shutter this dump and retire in filthy wealth.
And I told him, “Are you nuts?”
Retire? Do you know the power of what you do on that stage?
I’ve shrunk the flock.
[Cy] No. You’ve radicalized them.
That is power.
In a small town, there are only so many witches to burn and zealots to activate.
Your flame lacks fuel.
But on the Internet, wildfire.
This money.
Your cult of personality.
Are you kidding me?
Give me four years.
You could be president.
Together we can build a real empire.
As father and son.
Like in Star Wars? Yeah. Exactly, like the Rebels.
Oh.
His ministry and my political instincts fueled by enough money.
Can you imagine what we could do in Christ’s name?
Yeah. Yeah, I think I can.
First, I told him, and I’ll admit this is a little personal, first I told him we need to burn this flock.
They’re a liability.
If they associate themselves with us, show up on cable news, even want a place in this thing…
We need to burn them off like leeches.
[Jud] That’s why he torched them all.
‘Cause of your petty vindictiveness.
One of them might have killed him for it.
You know that, right?
Getting back to this vast fortune.
So it’s yours now?
Technically, yes.
Technically?
He didn’t tell you where it was.
[Cy] No.
His accounts are empty. There’s nothing.
So where is it?
And then, I realized, 50 years ago, what was the safest way for Prentice to hide $80 million?
A Swiss bank account.
[Benoit] Aha!
And so all you need to do is find that account number.
No luck there?
[sighs in exasperation] It has to be written down somewhere.
Martha files everything and it isn’t here.
I don’t know.
Here. I thought it might be a code because he kept saying, “Eve’s Apple would be restored to the tree.”
That was a thing.
As if Eve’s Apple is the fortune.
But a Swiss account, we’re looking for 19 numbers, so it doesn’t work.
Vera, did he ever tell you anything?
Even if he did, I would go to my grave before giving it to you.
Yeah.
You’d have done anything to keep the prodigal son from getting the fortune.
It burns you up.
You bitter hag.
That money is one psalm in the Bible of my bitterness, you fucking child.
You should come and get your shit, it’ll be out on the street. [scoffs]
[door opens, closes]
You. You’re a detective. I’ll pay you.
I don’t care, this is very important, my inheritance and future political career depends on it.
Can you think of anything related to Eve’s Apple that might contain that number?
Oh, um… Mmmm. [sniffles] But if you think of anything, you’ll call me?
Oh, yeah. You bet.
All right.
[engine starts]
[intriguing music plays]
We should look everywhere.
It might be, uh, sewn in the lining.
Etched in the metal.
[ripping]
[Benoit sighs]
[hollow thudding]
This is hollow.
Yeah. Do it.
[sighs]
[sighs]
[clatters]
Remind me to file this.
File that.
It doesn’t make sense.
I know.
An 80milliondollar fortune.
But if Eve’s Apple is the fortune and it’s not a pile of cash in a Swiss account somewhere, what is it?
What?
They must have misprinted the date on this.
It says the crypt opening thing was ordered last Wednesday.
That can’t be right.
Who would preorder burial equipment for a man who isn’t dead?
Someone who knew with great certainty when their day and hour would come.
Give me that.
Oh, that’s computer printed.
That’s not a misprint. That’s it.
Whoever called in that order, that’s the key.
Okay. Yeah. Yeah.
[line ringing]
[telephone ringing]
[pop music playing faintly]
Steel Wheels Construction. This is Louise.
Hello, Louise. It’s Father Jud from Perpetual Fortitude.
Oh. Hello.
Hi, Louise. We had a piece of your construction equipment here today.
Uh, a forklift to open a, um… a crypt.
Oh, yeah. I know. It’s not too often we get a crypt opening order.
Great. So I need to know…
I actually processed that order.
I do all the processing. Yeah. What I need to know, Louise, is…
I run this place with my brother James.
Right.
He takes orders but I process them.
Yeah. Right.
So the reason I’m calling, Louise, is to…
I’ve been to that church of yours, but I don’t think you were there.
No, I… I’m new, relatively new here.
Congratulations.
Louise, I… I have to ask…
No, it was an older guy. Father… Is he…
Monsignor, Monsignor.
Father Monsignor, okay, well…
Louise…
He was preaching when I went and I gotta tell you, that is not a nice man. But I am sorry that he…
Okay.
…yikes, died and, you know, for all y’all’s loss…
Yeah, it’s a terrible tragedy for everyone, Louise.
Can I… I have to, uh, interrupt.
I have a question.
Yeah.
Uh, the order for the forklift.
I need to know who placed the order.
James takes the orders and…
James takes the orders.
…he’s left for the day.
Can I have James’ number?
This is very important. We need to find out who placed that order.
No, no. I don’t think I can do that…
No, it’s very important.
Excuse me, Father.
It’s very…
What I can do, as I was saying, is I can get that information for you and then I will give you a buzz back.
That’s it. That’s great.
And if you could call James now, I would appreciate it so much.
Thank you, Louise.
And she’ll call you back.
I will. Hey, Father, could I ask you something?
Yeah, it’s… Though, I mean…
Well, if you can make it quick.
This is a priority for us right now.
Maybe she could call you back and…
Father Jud would you… Could you…
Louise?
[scoffs]
[Louise] Oh, God. Louise?
[sighs] Will you pray for me? Uh…
Yeah, of course.
Can I ask what for?
[Louise sniffles] Uh… It’s, uh, my mother.
She’s sick?
Yeah. Um, she’s in hospice.
I’m so sorry, Louise.
Uh, she won’t talk to me. We fought last time we talked. Uh, she has a tumor in her brain that’s affecting her, and it’s making her say really terrible things, and so I said bad things back and now I’m afraid that that’s gonna be the last thing that we ever say to each other.
[tearfully] Father, I, um…
I’m feeling pretty alone, um, right now.
[crying softly] I’m so sorry, Louise.
You’re not alone.
I’m right here.
I’m here.
Can you tell me your mother’s name?
[clicks tongue softly]
[sighs softly]
[thunder rumbling]
[wind gusting]
[inhales]
[exhales sharply]
I pray that Barbara may feel her daughter’s love.
That it will comfort her in this time, and, Lord, I pray for Louise.
Be with her and give her wisdom and guidance.
Hold her in your healing arms and let her know she is loved.
She is not alone.
This we pray through Christ our Lord. Amen.
Okay, Louise.
You have my number.
Any time, day or night, I’m here for you.
This church is here for you.
[door opens]
Bless you. Okay.
[panting] Storm. I came to close up.
[Jud] I’ll get the church.
You take care of the rectory.
[wind gusting] Don’t follow me, Blanc. I’m done.
And, uh, why exactly?
I’ve had a “road to Damascus” thing.
Paul had a holy revelation on the road to Damascus.
Yes, I know. He was struck blind and all that hogwash.
Probably just a case of pink eye.
But he was not on the verge of solving a murder when it happened.
I mean, what do you think we’re doing here?
Why do you think I became a priest?
No bullshit. Really. Why?
[wind howling]
[thunder rumbling]
You felt guilt.
For taking a life. And the church, it offered you a place to hide and a clear method to give you a sense of absolution.
The guy I killed in the ring, I hated him.
I remember, I knew he was in trouble and I kept going and going until I felt him break.
It wasn’t an accident.
I killed him with hate in my heart.
There’s no hiding from that, there’s no solving it.
God didn’t hide me or fix me.
He loves me when I’m guilty.
That’s what I should be doing for these people.
Not this whodunnit game.
No, now wait a minute.
[wind gusting]
Excuse me. Excuse me, I…
Would you look at me when I’m talking to you?
We’re looking for a murderer.
This is not a game.
It is a game!
Solving it, winning it.
Getting your big checkmate moment.
And by using me in it, you’re setting me against my real and only purpose in life.
Which is not to fight the wicked and bring them to justice, but to serve them and bring them to Christ.
Otherwise, I’m just as bad as Wicks.
Making it about me and not Jesus.
Listen, you don’t have to understand, Blanc.
But just please, please, please, please let me be.
[intriguing music plays]
[thunder rumbling]
Can you say that again?
No.
About making it about you, not Jesus.
Like Wicks, you said.
Father, this is important.
Help me understand!
We are here to serve the world, not beat it.
That’s what Christ did.
So?
So when Wicks was talking about fighting the world for Christ’s sake, he wasn’t talking about Christ, he was talking about his own ego.
And power.
He was never talking about Christ.
Yes, over and over he talked about Christ rising in power.
Getting his revenge on the unfaithful.
Eve’s Apple is the treasure.
“Eve’s Apple restored to the tree.”
Now, what does that mean?
Blanc. I don’t know.
And I don’t care.
[sirens approaching]
[thunder rumbling]
That’ll be Geraldine coming for her update on the case.
Now, Father, you’re right.
This is my game, not yours.
Why don’t you head back to the rectory?
I’ll handle her.
Thank you.
Make sure the door’s shut when you leave.
Hope you catch your killer, Blanc.
Thank you. I… I will.
[sirens wailing]
[indistinct police radio chatter]
Father Jud?
Father Jud.
He’s not here.
Come.
I want you to search those back rooms and that closet thing too.
[thunder rumbling distantly]
Oh.
It’s good, right?
[Geraldine] Great, actually.
Especially the part where Gideon Fell walks you through the possible solutions of a lockeddoor crime.
Mm.
Yeah.
You covered three of them, then you stopped.
Now, having read the fourth, I know why.
See, I rewatched the video and I realized something.
[suspenseful music plays]
From the moment Jud enters the closet, until the first of the flock has a line of sight into that closet is nine seconds.
Nine seconds alone and unseen.
Plenty of time to do the deed with a concealed knife. That’s how it was done, right?
No games.
No bullshit. That’s how it was done.
[thunder rumbling distantly]
Yes.
[scoffs] And you knew. You knew all along and you toyed with that poor kid like a cat with a mouse.
No.
I don’t have the whole picture just yet.
If you could give me a little more time…
No.
I’m gonna be able to get…
No!
I found my killer and I’m bringing him in.
Where is he?
[thunder crashing]
[wind gusting]
[slow suspenseful music plays]
[breathing heavily]
[muffled thudding]
[thudding continues]
[muffled thudding]
[deep rumbling]
[breathing heavily]
[Jud] Sam!
[panting]
[yelps, groans]
[panting]
[ominous music plays]
[highpitched distortion]
[panting echoing]
[breathing heavily]
[rhythmic thumping]
[thumping accelerates]
[distorted yelling]
[suspenseful music plays]
[gasps]
[gasps, groans]
[panting]
[Benoit] Who’s there?
[gasps, grunts]
Wait!
[Geraldine] Blanc?
Here.
[gasps] Oh, shit. Who’s that?
The groundskeeper, Samson.
What the hell happened?
Oh…
[Benoit] Mm. [mutters, clears throat]
[Geraldine] Uh…
Mm. [clicks tongue] Yeah.
Okay.
Okay, Wicks was 100% medically dead dead.
I mean, we know this, I’m just… just saying, right?
Right.
[Geraldine] Okay, then I can also say out loud, a man can’t just rise from the dead.
I mean, there’s obviously some ScoobyDoo shit going on here.
“ScoobyDoobyDoo.”
Praise to God!
Praise and glory to the Almighty!
Praise Him!
[siren wails]
Praise God!
Praise and glory to the Almighty.
He hath raised His Son.
Hey, Ritz.
Set a perimeter on the road.
News is gonna spread fast and I don’t want any lookieloos.
You got it.
Chief!
What?
That motiondetector light there, it’s also a camera.
But it’s not hooked up to anything.
[Geraldine] A camera, huh?
I don’t know. Maybe it’s recording something on a chip inside.
Why don’t you bring it into the media lab?
Hallelujah, praise God.
He has raised up His servant from the dead.
Hey, do me a favor? Tape off this entire area, down to the grove.
Got it.
It’s a homicide scene.
The groundskeeper is dead.
[somber music plays]
[screams, cries]
[sobbing] No! Please!
Oh, shit.
[Martha] No! No, no, no!
[Geraldine] Can I get some help?
Get help! Martha.
No! Oh, no, no!
Martha, you need to back up.
Oh, no!
Martha…
[sobbing] Flee into the dark, you murderer!
[panting]
[dramatic music plays]
But he has returned!
And he brings vengeance! He brings death!
[grunts]
[sniffles]
[panting]
[music fades]
[cell phone buzzing]
[gasps]
[wind howling]
[cell phone clacks]
This is Father Jud.
Oh, Father Jud, it’s Louise.
How you doing? Uh…
Yeah… [hesitates] Hi, Louise.
I… I hope it’s not too late, but you said it was urgent, so I just wanted to tell you… I spoke to James and the order for the forklift was actually placed by Monsignor Wicks. He spoke to James directly about it, so I do hope that this clears things up. Hey, God bless you, Father, and you have yourself a good night, okay?
Uh… Yeah.
Yeah, you too, Louise. [pants]
[cell phone beeps]
[sinister music plays]
[yells]
[thunderclap]
[pants]
[grunts]
[cell phone ringing]
Jeez.
Yes?
Slow down, Martha. What?
What?
[thuds]
[Lee] It’s a miracle.
Bullshit.
No, it happened.
Martha said the tomb is empty.
I’m calling everyone. I’m on my way now.
Did you, uh…
What are you doing? You don’t smoke.
I did.
I smoked for 15 years.
Did Lee call you? Did he tell you?
Yep.
Okay. Well, I’m gonna go witness a miracle.
You enjoy your cigarette indoors.
[door opens]
[door closes]
[vibrates]
[heavy knocking on door]
[slow suspenseful music plays]
[footsteps approaching]
[heavy knocking on door]
Praise be.
It’s accomplished.
[vibrates]
[line ringing] Come on.
Come on, it’s…
[cell phone beeps] He’s got it.
All right, so… it’s not great quality…
It’s fine.
…but, uh…
What am I looking at here?
Okay.
Um, yeah, so, it records anytime there’s motion and this clip is four seconds later.
[mouse and keyboard clacking] Okay?
[knock on door] Prints from the gardening tool.
We didn’t run the full database check, just the suspects you questioned.
It’s Father Jud.
Where is he?
I sincerely wish I knew.
[music intensifies, fades]
[chiming]
[thunder rumbling]
[indistinct police radio chatter]
Blanc. Blanc!
I’m gonna do it. I’m gonna… turn myself…
[shushes]
[officer 1] …388.
[officer 2] 388, en route.
[officer 1] 433. I’m turning myself in.
No you are not.
[on radio, loudly]
♪ Skimbleshanks, the railway cat! ♪
[Benoit clears throat]
I did it. I killed Samson.
I’m guilty. I have to confess.
Let me out.
Listen.
You’re gonna tell me exactly what happened, but right now, how do I get to Dr. Nat’s house?
Dr. Nat?
Yes, quickly.
I regret my stalling.
I only hope we’re not too late.
Now, just get down!
[tires screeching]
[thunder rumbling]
Hail Mary, full of grace the Lord is with you.
Blessed art thou amongst women… sir, that I respect you.
I respect the badge.
But this is our church and I’m not telling you that I’m gonna resort to violence, but we’re gonna stay here all night if we have to. We are seeing that crypt!
Is it real?
[Lee] They won’t let us in.
[breath trembling] I need to see.
Please, I need to see.
[brakes screech]
[wind chime tinkling softly]
[slow suspenseful music plays]
[door creaking]
Dr. Nat?
[glass crunching underfoot]
[sighs heavily]
[sniffs, gags] Oh, God.
What’s that smell?
[Jud breathing heavily]
Just wait here.
Blanc.
[Benoit] Yep.
[switch clicks]
[grim music plays]
Oh, God.
Right.
[inhales sharply]
Oh, Lord, that is… [coughs]
[groaning]
[Jud] Wicks.
[Benoit] Yeah, that’s… It’s him.
[Jud] Is he…
Yeah.
I mean, for what it’s worth these days. [clears throat] Let’s see now. Let’s…
[groans]
Okay.
This might get unpleasant.
I mean, more unpleasant.
[squeaks]
[liquid draining]
[dramatic sinister music plays]
Dr. Nat.
In the flesh. Yeah…
Or, what’s left of it.
[clears throat]
[Benoit exhales]
[line ringing]
Geraldine, it’s… it’s Blanc. Um…
Yeah, he’s standing right here.
[hesitates] Listen to me.
You’re gonna wanna come to Dr. Nat’s house.
[breathing heavily]
There’s a body. Or two.
It’s all here.
Yes, yeah. It’s… it’s finished, yeah.
[stair creaks]
[sighs] I’ll call you back.
Father Jud. Wait, wait.
I killed Samson. I have to do this.
I have to do it of my own free will or it won’t mean anything.
[female officer over radio] Plate check.
Copy that. Any available units to respond… Would you call Geraldine for me, please?
Say Father Jud’s returned to his church and he’s ready to confess.
[door creaking]
[door thuds]
Father Jud.
I’m here to arrest you for the murder of Monsignor Jefferson Wicks and Samson Holt.
And you’re a person of interest in the death of Dr. Nathaniel Sharp.
[splutters] Nat is dead?
Murdered in his home.
We also recovered Wicks’ body. It’s over.
Anything you say can be used against you in a court of law.
But if you’d like to confess to anything, this seems like a pretty great place to do it.
Yeah.
Years ago, I murdered a man in a boxing ring.
I killed him with hate in my heart.
Last night, that same sin rose in me and in a moment of fear and rage, I…
[“Overture” from The Phantom Of The Opera playing] I’m sorry, that was dramatic, but I needed you to stop talking.
No. Father Jud…
I was about to explain to everyone…
Sit down and listen.
Stop talking.
Please, let him. You were continuing…
Continue, you said last night…
In a moment of fear and rage…
I was about to do it…
[dramatically] You shall not silence the voice of the Lord!
But sit now and behold the wickedness and shame of the guilty laid bare before you all!
[whispering] What are you doing?
[clears throat]
[smacks lips]
Let us begin with Wicks’ murder.
Right here on Good Friday.
The impossible crime.
And, Geraldine, you were correct in your deduction.
When Monsignor Wicks collapsed in that closet space, he wasn’t dead.
He wasn’t even stabbed, not yet.
The flask he kept stashed in the breaker box was spiked with a very powerful tranquilizer.
[suspenseful music plays]
He drank from it.
Fortified himself.
And within minutes, fell to the floor, unconscious.
[flask clangs]
[Benoit] The clanky clunk.
Leaving him defenseless and giving the killer their chance to enter the closet and deliver the deadly blow.
I… I said that already.
Father Jud.
No. The knife was in his back when I found him.
There’s something in his back.
So how? When? It’s impossible. I saw.
What did you see?
The red devil head.
Blood you assumed was Wicks’. Now, I showed you the answer to this, did you see?
Il Diavolo.
The pizza bar. The photograph.
You thought you saw, but that wasn’t it, no. It was a second identical lamp. A second identical devil head.
Yeah.
And it was also missing. Two devils.
[Benoit] Yes.
Why two?
And why painted red?
It wasn’t red though. It’s red now.
[Benoit] The same red as the Good Friday vestments.
The same exact red as the mysterious thread found in the closet.
Because the second devil head was there all the time. Sewn to the back of his vestments. Hollow, light, and filled with a small squib of blood triggered by an RF remote.
[static crackles]
[Benoit] Set off at the exact right moment.
[Jud] Monsignor?
The doctor.
A voice of authority who can wait for the discovery he needs before taking charge. There’s something in his back.
Wait. Don’t touch it.
A moment of distraction presents itself.
[imperceptible]
And the deed is quickly done. His final task, to remove the incriminating druglaced flask. But where was it? It was gone.
The one hiccup in his plan.
The result of a moment of foolish grace by Father Jud who concealed the flask to hide Wicks’ drinking and returned later to retrieve it.
My God.
Nat.
Why?
[Vera] Wicks was going to scorch the earth.
He was going to ruin him.
No. The bigger why.
The why that brought you here.
Why do all this insane, elaborate stuff?
The theatricality? The impossible crime.
Why?
Indeed.
Okay, so… if Dr. Nat killed Wicks, who killed Nat?
Well, now we get to it.
Not some fiddly lockeddoor mystery with devices and clues, but a much, much larger scheme.
One whose roots run to the bedrock of this church.
And one which draws me, an unbeliever in every sense of the word, into the realm of belief.
To understand this case, I had to look at the myth that was being constructed.
Not to solve whether it was real or not, but to feel in my soul the essence of that which it strove to convey.
A holy priest.
Struck down by no man, but by the hand of Satan himself.
Laid to rest in the sealed tomb of his father, but then risen by the will of God.
Risen as something new.
No longer a fallible man, but now a symbol of the Lord’s power over death.
His justice for the holy.
His vengeance for the wicked.
Okay. And now, what really happened?
Yes. Yes.
[intriguing music plays] It is time to break this tawdry facade of miracles and resurrections and reveal what really happened.
It is time for Benoit Blanc’s final checkmate over the mysteries of faith!
[exhales heavily]
[solemn string music plays]
[sighs softly]
Blanc, are you… Are you okay?
Damascus.
Damascus?
Like… a road to Damascus thing?
Yes, yes, Damascus.
Shit. [sighs] Blanc?
[inhales, clicks tongue]
[exhales]
I cannot solve this case.
What?
Are you saying that your conclusion, Benoit Blanc, is that Monsignor Wicks rose from the dead?
That it was a miracle?
I’m saying I cannot solve this case.
[cell phone clicks]
That works.
Thank you.
[Jud] Blanc?
If you know what really happened, you should tell everyone.
Is this you sparing our faith or being respectful or something?
Because we deserve the truth.
It is not.
[breath shaking]
I need the truth.
[scoffs] Can’t you just give us the answer?
Isn’t that what all this is for?
And would you consider blurbing my book?
[hesitates] No.
[Geraldine] Okay. All right.
Show’s over. Everyone out.
Out. Out.
[officer 1] Yeah, can you stand back, sir?
[indistinct chatter]
[officer 2] Okay, can we keep them back…
[mellow intriguing music plays]
I add another chapter and then we’re… we’re ready.
We’re ready to publish. Trust me, Alan.
Call Random House, everybody.
It’s gonna be huge!
What we’ve witnessed is a miracle confirmed by Benoit Blanc himself.
The world will know what happened today here at Chimney Rock.
You can find out yourself.
Follow my YouTube channel @CyDraven…
What a mess.
I assume they’ll arrest Father Jud now.
Yes.
I suppose they will.
What the hell was that?
Road to Damascus.
Scales fell from my eyes.
So what? Facts, schmacks?
You believe in God and all this mishegoss is real?
No, no. God is a fiction.
My revelation came from… from Father Jud.
His example to have grace.
[door opens] Grace for my enemy.
Grace for the broken.
Grace for those who deserve it the least.
But who need it the most.
[breathing shakily]
For the guilty.
[Martha] Mr. Blanc.
You know the truth.
I do, yes.
And you made yourself the fool just now.
So that you could do this of your own free will.
And now you better do it. Quickly.
Thank you.
Father Jud.
[breathing shakily]
[softly] What do I do?
What you were born to do.
Be her priest.
Take her confession.
Bless me, Father, for I have sinned.
It is a week since my last confession.
I told myself it started with pure intent.
But the truth is it started with a lie.
Prentice.
[intriguing string music plays]
[Martha] Prentice. I saw him take his final communion.
This is Eve’s Apple, Martha.
My entire cursed fortune.
All the sin in the world.
All that Eve hungers for.
I have trapped it.
It shall never again be plucked by evil hands.
The body of Christ.
[music turns ominous]
[groaning]
[Prentice gulps, groans]
[exhales]
[Martha] He took the jewel to his grave.
[suspenseful music plays]
I swore that I would protect this great secret. But Grace, she discovered that he had bought the diamond.
I don’t know how.
She knew her fancy brands.
What would come in a custom-made Fabergé box, itself worth maybe $20,000? Not a trinket or a plastic Jesus, no. Something facet-cut, worth a fortune. A jewel.
But she didn’t know where he hid it.
So that night…
She didn’t desecrate the church in anger. [Benoit] No, she was looking for the hidden jewel. [Grace sobbing] [Benoit] A dark life of desperation. A prisoner to shame and judgment. It was her one way out.
That poor girl.
Martha, what did you say to her?
I know where he hid it.
And you’ll never find it.
You harlot whore.
[yells] Where is it?
[screams]
[yelling]
[giggling] Where is it, you little shit?
I kept the secret of Eve’s Apple locked in my heart for 60 years.
My terrible burden.
Until…
[melancholic music plays]
I challenged you to confess it.
[imperceptible]
[Martha] With defiant pride, I confessed.
[panting]
To the wrong priest.
[breath trembles]
Time is of the essence now.
Last Sunday, in the rectory, Vera confronted Wicks and you learned about Cy.
I could accept that he had strayed.
[imperceptible]
But as he spoke, something became clear. This was something much bigger. He was embracing that terrible boy. That’s when I suspected.
So you call the construction company.
Thank you, James.
[Martha] And I was certain. He had ordered the equipment to open the crypt to steal the diamond for his own greed and lust for power. The corrupting sin of Eve’s Apple would be unearthed and this church would fall because of everything Prentice had warned me about. I had failed him.
All my life, I was not the bad one. I was the good one.
The faithful one.
Serving and protecting the church.
If I failed in that, what is my life?
I understand.
My sole purpose and I failed.
Unless…
[breath trembles]
Unless…
Unless I could…
I could steal the jewel first and get rid of it forever. And with the same stroke, raise Wicks up as a miraculous risen saint. Not a fallible man, but a symbol that would save my church. All it would take is a miracle. So I formed my plan.
Wicks’ death must be a holy mystery.
Unsolvable and divine.
But you couldn’t do it alone.
No.
A weak man, I thought. Desperate. Someone who would fall in line to save the church and stay in line to cover his shame.
And who had access to medicalgrade tranquilizers.
Yes. And that.
It all went according to plan. Oh, God. [breathing heavily] My vanity.
So wicked.
[Jud] Martha.
I understand, I promise, I do.
Keep going. I’m here.
[Martha] I didn’t reckon the cost.
Forgive me, Samson.
Strong Samson, faithful Samson.
Samson. Who made the coffins.
[grunts] Shit.
[Martha] You will rise again.
It will be okay.
You will rise again.
It will be okay. [exhales]
[melancholic music plays]
I promise.
He didn’t understand why we were doing it.
Anything for you, my angel.
[Martha] But he trusted me. Because he loved me.
Oh, Lord. [sobs] How did it go so wrong?
[thunder crashing]
[Martha] It was supposed to be so simple. The doctor gives the signal.
[cell phone chimes]
[Martha] Samson retrieves the jewel. The Lazarus door serves its purpose.
[beeps]
All caught on camera the way we planned. Dr. Nat would drive off with Wicks’ body in his truck and dispose of it in that nasty gook in his cellar. And the next day, Samson would tell the tale of the risen saint and his word of blessing to his faithful groundskeeper before ascending back into heaven. A miracle. It would have been perfect.
I wasn’t supposed to be there.
You most certainly were not.
[Benoit] Did you know what had happened when you found Samson’s body?
I had an idea.
[sobbing] No, no!
But I had to be sure.
[Nat] Praise be.
It’s accomplished.
[clatters] Oh. Oh. Oh.
[Martha] Then he told me the fairy tale of how everything had gone according to plan. It was only then that I told him I’d been to the crypt. And I knew he was lying. [gulps]
[Martha] And then he told me the truth.
[thunder rumbling]
[yelps, groans]
Shit. We can’t let him see us.
[Jud pants, groans]
[gasps softly]
[Nat] Jesus.
[Martha] My second mistake. Underestimating the temptation of Eve’s Apple. Our agreed mission was to destroy it or throw it in the sea. But all this power will I give thee. Christ himself could resist temptation, but this desperate little man, all that stood in his way was Samson and I. Now, here was his opportunity.
To remove his obstacles.
[thunder crashes]
Frame a young priest with a violent past and keep the jewel.
He took it.
[yells]
Then all that remained in his way was me.
[imperceptible]
He had poisoned my coffee with a lethal dose of pentobarbital. No remedy once ingested. Mm, painless. A little numbness in the lips. Then in ten minutes, time for your final prayer. Then he begged me to understand why he was doing all this. That the money would lure back his harpy wife, blah, blah, blah. I told him I understood. I understood why he did it.
[clatters] Oh.
[Martha] I had understood it all.
[Martha] These things I did with hatred in my heart.
[Martha] Vengeance is mine, said the Lord. And that is the story the crime scene will tell the world, but… [squeaks] [liquid sloshing]
[Martha] …inside my heart, I know.
[switch clicks]
Vengeance is mine.
These sins I confess to you, Father.
[breathing heavily] I have lied, I have killed, and now I have topped it all off with a real doozy.
[breathing heavily]
[gasps]
Father. Quickly now, quickly.
[hesitates] What’s happening?
I knew when I saw her lips… it was already too late.
[sighs]
She’s taken the pentobarbital.
Oh. Oh, God. Call the ambulance now!
On it!
There might be a poison kit in the prowler!
[labored breathing]
Forgive me, Father, for all you have endured.
Forgive me, Lord, for… for Wicks and Nat and…
Samson.
[sobs] My sweet Samson.
And Grace.
[huffs]
[Jud] Martha.
Grace.
You’re safe now.
Let it go.
Let the hatred go.
Grace.
Yes.
I see it now.
That poor girl.
Forgive me, Grace.
Father… you’re really good at this.
[chuckles]
God, the father of mercies, through the death and resurrection of His Son has reconciled the world to Himself and poured out the Holy Spirit for the forgiveness of sins, and through the ministry of the Church, may God grant you pardon and peace, and I absolve you of your sins.
In the name of the Father and of the Son and the Holy Spirit.
[clangs]
Shit.
[Jud breathing heavily]
[mellow cello music plays]
[Jud] The jewel was never found. The church closed for a while. The flock, what was left of them, scattered. Some got what they wanted only to discover the one thing every holy man knows… God has a sense of humor. And some got a fresh start. Maybe to find a path that’s theirs, I hope so. And some got their miracle. Not being cured or fixed, but finding the sustaining power to wake up every day and do what we’re here to do in spite of the pain. Daily bread.
[music ends]
[exhales softly]
And that’s what I pray for with you.
That you find what you’re looking for.
[clock ticking]
Where is it? You know.
No! Cy, Cy!
Goddamn it, I know you both know.
This is your last chance or we’re gonna drag you into court.
[Langstrom] Mr. Wicks, control yourself.
We’d hoped this mediation would resolve this matter.
She gave it to them and they’re hiding it. I know.
We’ve allowed your representatives to search the church and rectory thoroughly.
They found nothing.
[Cy sighs] Also, Mr. Blanc was there when Martha passed and he denies anything untoward.
[church bell tolling]
[Cy] Hey.
Hey!
Any hint you’ve sold it, any big charity donations, you fix the roof, you upgrade your shitty communion wine, I will watch, I will audit, I will find out.
I hope you come back to the church someday, Cy.
Your real inheritance is in Christ.
[scoffs softly]
[car doors close]
[engine starts] Little punk bitch.
[tires screech]
His video with you is still trending.
Yes.
“Benoit Blanc ‘pwned’.”
Owned with a “P”. Whatever that means.
We keep pushing the facts out there.
Martha, what really happened.
But it doesn’t seem to matter.
Wicks truthers keep flooding our Facebook.
It’s an outhouse fire.
Such a time to be alive.
You’re gonna be very popular once you open.
Maybe not in a good way.
Are you ready to take that on?
Let ’em come.
Good luck, kid.
[Benoit] Listen, uh… Um…
[clicks tongue] I’m…
I’m… I’m gonna go.
[sighs] Hmm.
[Jud chuckles] Uh, my first Mass is coming up if… if you wanna stick around.
Um… That’s so nice of you.
There is, uh… nothing I would rather not do.
Toodleoo.
[“Come On Up To The House” by Tom Waits playing]
[lighter clicks, flicks]
♪ Well, the moon is broken
And the sky is cracked ♪
♪ Come on up to the house ♪
♪ The only things that you can see
Is all that you lack ♪
Welcome!
♪ Come on up to the house ♪
♪ All your crying don’t do no good ♪
♪ Come on up to the house ♪
♪ Come down off the cross
We can use the wood ♪
♪ You gotta come on up to the house ♪
♪ Come on up to the house ♪
♪ Come on up to the house ♪
♪ The world is not my home
I’m just apassing through ♪
♪ You got to come on up to the house ♪
♪ There’s no light in the tunnel
No irons in the fire ♪
♪ Come on up to the house ♪
♪ And you’re singing lead soprano
In a junk man’s choir ♪
♪ You got to come on up to the house ♪
♪ Does life seem nasty
Brutish and short ♪
♪ Come on up to the house ♪
♪ The seas are stormy
And you can’t find no port ♪
♪ Got to come on up to the house, yeah ♪
♪ You gotta come on up to the house ♪
♪ Come on up to the house ♪
♪ The world is not my home
I’m just apassing through ♪
♪ You got to come on up
To the house, yeah ♪
♪ You gotta come on up to the house ♪
♪ Come on up to the house ♪
♪ The world is not my home
I’m just apassing through ♪
♪ You got to come on up to the house ♪
♪ There’s nothing in the world
That you can do ♪
♪ You gotta come on up to the house ♪
♪ And you been whipped by the forces
That are inside you ♪
♪ Gotta come on up to the house ♪
♪ Well, you’re high on top
Of your mountain of woe ♪
♪ Gotta come on up to the house ♪
♪ Well, you know you should surrender
But you can’t let it go ♪
♪ You gotta come on up
To the house, yeah ♪
♪ Gotta come on up to the house ♪
♪ Gotta come on up to the house ♪
♪ The world is not my home
I’m just apassing through ♪
♪ You gotta come on up to the house ♪
♪ Gotta come on up to the house ♪
♪ You gotta come on up to the house ♪
♪ Oh, yeah ♪
[string music plays]
