Avatar: Fire and Ash (2025)
Director: James Cameron
Stars: Sam Worthington (Jake Sully) Zoe Saldaña (Neytiri te Tskaha Mo’at’ite), Sigourney Weaver (Kiri te Suli Kìreysì’ite and Dr. Grace Augustine), Stephen Lang (Colonel Miles Quaritch), Oona Chaplin (Varang), Kate Winslet (Ronal te Natsira Tan’ite), Cliff Curtis (Tonowari te Tsika’u), Joel David Moore (Dr. Norm Spellman), CCH Pounder (Mo’at), Edie Falco (General Frances Ardmore), Brendan Cowell (Captain Mick Scoresby), Jemaine Clement (Dr. Ian Garvin), Giovanni Ribisi (Parker Selfridge), David Thewlis (Peylak), Britain Dalton (Lo’ak te Suli Tsyeyk’itan), Jack Champion (Miles “Spider” Socorro), Trinity Jo-Li Bliss (Tuktirey “Tuk” te Suli Neytiri’ite), Jamie Flatters (Neteyam te Suli Tsyeyk’itan), Bailey Bass (Tsireya “Reya” te Tsika’u Ronal’ite), Filip Geljo (Aonung te Tsika’u Tonowari’itan), Duane Evans Jr. (Rotxo), Matt Gerald (Corporal Lyle Wainfleet), Dileep Rao (Dr. Max Patel)
* * *
James Cameron has always been a director who mistakes enormity for profundity. His films are like aircraft carriers—impressive engineering feats that take forever to turn around and require enormous crews just to keep from sinking. But with Avatar: Fire and Ash, something unexpected has happened: Cameron has finally discovered moral ambiguity, and it suits him better than anyone might have predicted.
The original Avatar was a gorgeous contradiction—a half-billion-dollar sermon against corporate greed, a technological marvel preaching the virtues of primitivism. The Na’vi were noble savages rendered in pixels, their blue bodies moving through phosphorescent forests with the grace of screensavers come to life. They were beautiful, they were pure, and they were boring. Cameron gave us an alien civilization with all the complexity of a greeting card. The sequel, The Way of Water, offered more of the same ecological beatitude, now with whales. One began to suspect that Cameron’s Pandora would remain forever a kind of spiritual resort, where enlightened aliens communed with nature while evil humans did evil things.
The Mangkwan—the “Ash People”—shatter this cozy arrangement. They are Na’vi who worship fire instead of the planetary goddess Eywa, who have rejected the sacred prohibitions against technology, who recruit murderers and exiles into their ranks, and who gleefully ally themselves with the human colonizers in exchange for flamethrowers and assault rifles. They are, in short, exactly what the franchise needed: proof that the Na’vi are not exempt from the corrupting influences of trauma, resentment, and power. Cameron has finally admitted that his indigenous aliens are people rather than principles.
The backstory Cameron has constructed for the Mangkwan possesses a grim logic that the previous films’ villainy lacked. During the childhood of their leader, Varang, a volcanic eruption incinerated their Hometree and decimated their population. The survivors cried out to Eywa for salvation. Eywa did not come. This silence—this perceived abandonment by their deity—became the singularity around which an entirely new culture condensed. If the Great Mother would not protect them, they would master the force that destroyed them. They turned to fire.
There is something almost Nietzschean in this origin story, a theological wound that metastasizes into nihilism. While other Na’vi clans view natural disasters as tragic but necessary components of cosmic balance, the Mangkwan concluded that Eywa was either weak, indifferent, or simply absent from their domain. They abandoned the Three Laws of Eywa—prohibitions against stone construction, the wheel, and metalworking—and became the first Na’vi clan to willfully embrace technology. In the vacuum left by their goddess, fire was elevated to deity status. Their leader explicitly states that fire is the only pure thing on Pandora because it cleanses, destroys, and allows for survival through dominance.
Cameron cited the Baining people of Papua New Guinea as his inspiration, specifically their nocturnal fire dances where masked men move through massive bonfires in trance states. He witnessed this ritual during a 2012 expedition and was struck by its hypnotic power. But Cameron, characteristically, has inverted the meaning. The Baining fire dance is a celebration—of birth, harvest, and the dead, a communion with forest spirits. The Mangkwan fire dance is a preparation for war, a nihilistic rejection of the very nature spirits the Baining honor. Cameron takes indigenous ritual and hollows it out, keeping the spectacle while discarding the soul. One suspects this says something about his relationship to his source material generally.
Varang herself is the film’s most compelling creation, and Oona Chaplin plays her with a coiled, reptilian intensity that makes the previous films’ villains look like cartoon bulldogs. Where Neytiri’s violence is protective, born of love for her family, Varang’s violence is retributive, born of abandonment. The costume designer developed a specific physicality based on the concept of a “closed heart”—most Na’vi move with their chests open, exposing their hearts in gestures of trust and connection. Varang wears a tight binding across her chest and moves from the pelvis and the eyes, guarded and predatory. She poisoned her own father at fifteen, viewing him as blinded by fear, and seized total control of the clan. She wields a pair of S-shaped double-ended blades that create a mesmerizing optical illusion when spinning, and she eagerly adopts the flamethrower provided by the RDA. By wielding the very element that destroyed her home against her enemies, she transforms from victim to disaster incarnate.
The alliance between Varang and the Recombinant Miles Quaritch is the film’s most interesting relationship—a bad romance between two beings drawn to each other’s strength and shared nihilism. It is also Cameron’s clearest articulation of colonial divide-and-conquer strategy. Quaritch provides advanced weaponry; Varang provides manpower, knowledge of terrain, and ruthlessness. Each party believes they are using the other. This mutual exploitation, with its echoes of historical colonial strategies like the weaponization of inter-tribal grievances in the Musket Wars, gives the film a political sophistication that the earlier installments entirely lacked.
The Mangkwan have also domesticated a new aerial predator called the Nightwraith, a four-winged creature with a hollow bony crest used as a battering ram. Varang rides a scarred specimen that she treats with utilitarian coldness, contrasting with the sacred bond between Jake Sully and his Ikran. This detail encapsulates everything Cameron is trying to say about the Mangkwan: they have instrumentalized what other Na’vi hold sacred. They use the neural bond not to share memory and healing but to inflict pain, extract truth, and dominate minds. They utilize toxins and hallucinogens to break the wills of their enemies. This weaponization of the sacred is considered an abomination by other clans, and Cameron clearly intends us to share this judgment.
Yet one cannot help noticing that Cameron is fascinated by what he condemns. The Mangkwan sequences are the film’s most visually arresting—the monochromatic palette of greys and blacks and dull reds, the ash-coated warriors with their scarification and body paint, the fire dances and the Nightwraiths wheeling against volcanic skies. There is an energy here that the earnest ecological communion of the other clans cannot match. Cameron films destruction with the same loving attention he brings to his bioluminescent forests, and one suspects his sympathies are more divided than he would admit.
The film’s climax brings tragedy that cements the Mangkwan as irredeemable. Ronal, the fierce spiritual leader of the reef people, enters battle despite being heavily pregnant. She is mortally wounded by Mangkwan forces, goes into labor on the battlefield, and dies moments after holding her newborn. It is the kind of scene designed to make audiences weep and hate, and Cameron executes it with his customary technical precision. But the real resolution comes through Kiri, Jake Sully’s mysterious daughter, who accepts her role as conduit for the planetary mind and unleashes a massive bio-electric surge that terrifies Varang. The goddess Varang deemed weak possesses power beyond her comprehension. She flees the battle, surviving to threaten future installments.
Cameron is arguing that fire is false power because it consumes its fuel and leaves only ash. In contrast, the water of the reef people connects, and the roots of the forest people sustain. Varang’s closed heart may make her formidable, but it leaves her spiritually hollow, ruling over a kingdom of dust. This is not a subtle thesis, and Cameron hammers it with his usual blunt-instrument technique. But there is something genuinely moving in the attempt to show that trauma can corrupt rather than ennoble, that indigenous peoples are not monolithically good, that the cycle of violence can swallow anyone.
The war is no longer a simple binary of invading humans versus defending Na’vi. It is now a triangular conflict involving internecine warfare, proxy battles, and shifting alliances. Cameron has discovered that grey makes for better drama than blue, even on Pandora. Whether he has the artistic restraint to explore these ambiguities rather than simply resolve them remains to be seen. For now, it is enough that he has finally allowed fire into his Eden, and found that it illuminates more than it destroys.
